Thanksgiving is supposed to be about family and gratitude, but this year, it felt more like stepping onto a battlefield I never agreed to join. What began as a disagreement over attending my sister-in-law Amy’s vegetarian Thanksgiving spiraled into my husband Jeremy threatening divorce. In the days that followed, I uncovered secrets that shattered the foundation of our marriage.

It all started with Amy’s message. She announced she’d be hosting Thanksgiving and declared it would be strictly vegetarian. “No meat or animal products allowed! Anyone who doesn’t respect this rule will be kicked out. Trust me, you won’t even miss them once you try my Tofurky roast!”

I laughed at the absurdity, recalling her history of poorly executed faux-meat dishes. Sharing the message with Jeremy, I expected him to find it equally ridiculous. Instead, his reaction stunned me.

“It’s just one meal, Belinda,” he said, his voice tight. “You can handle it.”

“I know I can handle it,” I shot back. “I just don’t want to.”

“Why does everything with Amy have to be such a big deal?” he snapped, running a hand through his hair. “It’s important to her. Can’t you just do something for her for once?”

His words stung. I was tired of always accommodating Amy’s demands. “This isn’t about the food,” I said. “Amy steamrolls everyone’s plans. Why should we spend Thanksgiving catering to her rules? Why can’t we just have a quiet dinner at home?”

Jeremy’s response left me breathless. “If you can’t be there for my family, maybe you shouldn’t be part of it anymore.”

Divorce. He was willing to throw away our marriage over Thanksgiving dinner. “You’d divorce me over this?” I asked, my voice trembling.

“It’s not just dinner,” he muttered. “It’s about support.”

@threadtalkpodcast AITA for not going to Vegan Thanksgiving? #reddit #aita #tifu #redditstory #redditstories #threadtalk #threadtalkpodcast #podcast #redditreadings ♬ original sound – ThreadTalk Podcast

Support, right. Except the support was always one-sided, with me constantly coming second to Amy. While I held my tongue, the truth simmered beneath the surface: Jeremy’s devotion to Amy went far beyond typical sibling concern. The late-night calls, the anxious glances—it all added up to something I couldn’t ignore.

Reluctantly, I agreed to attend Amy’s Thanksgiving. But the bitterness of that decision lingered, and Jeremy’s behavior in the days leading up to the holiday only deepened my unease. He became distant, leaving early and returning late, his shoulders hunched as though carrying an invisible weight. His preoccupation with our finances was especially strange; he’d always managed our money, but now he scrutinized every transaction with unsettling intensity.

One night, unable to shake my suspicions, I checked our joint account. Guilt whispered that I was crossing a line, but my need for answers drowned it out. My breath caught as I noticed small, regular withdrawals labeled “medical expenses.” A quick online search revealed that the doctor’s name belonged to a psychologist.

The discovery left me reeling. Was Jeremy in therapy? Why hadn’t he told me? The next night, I worked up the courage to ask. “Jeremy, are you… seeing a therapist?” I asked cautiously.

He hesitated before replying. “Yeah, sometimes,” he said, avoiding my eyes. “It’s been a stressful year.”

His words felt like a lie, and I couldn’t ignore the sinking feeling in my gut. But the truth emerged a few nights later when I overheard him on the phone.

“I told you I’d handle it,” he whispered, his tone uncharacteristically tender. “You don’t have to worry… Goodnight, Amy.”

Amy. Of course. It all came back to her.

The next morning, I confronted him. “Jeremy, what’s going on with Amy? The calls, the money—what are you hiding?”

Trapped, Jeremy finally confessed. “Amy has bipolar disorder,” he admitted. “A few years ago, she was hospitalized for months. When she got out, I was the only one she trusted. I’ve been helping her ever since.”

His words unraveled everything I thought I knew. The withdrawals covered Amy’s therapy and expenses. “Why didn’t you tell me?” I asked, anger and betrayal choking my voice.

“I didn’t think you needed to know,” he said quietly. “I wanted to protect her.”

“Protect her? You’ve been lying to me our entire marriage. About our money, about everything.”

“It wasn’t lying,” he insisted. “It was just… keeping the peace.”

His excuses fell flat. The realization hit me like a tidal wave: Jeremy’s loyalty to Amy had eclipsed his commitment to me. “You’re so focused on Amy that you’re willing to destroy our marriage over Thanksgiving dinner.”

“I didn’t know it would come to this,” he muttered.

“Well, it has.” I took a deep breath, summoning my resolve. “And now you have a choice—not between Amy and me, but between honesty and deceit. Between enabling her and setting boundaries. Between being her caretaker and being my husband.”

Jeremy hesitated, fear flickering in his eyes. “What if setting boundaries makes her worse?” he asked.

“What if it doesn’t?” I countered. “What if she’s stronger than you think?”

His silence was deafening. For the first time, I questioned whether our marriage could survive. Amy couldn’t continue to control our lives, but Jeremy’s fear of confronting her might make change impossible. As Thanksgiving loomed, I couldn’t help but wonder: was there still hope for us, or was it time to let go?